A creature [...] sighted at least 25 length in feet was seen in the St. Joseph river at various times. This frightened villagers so much that they would not go out at night. They scouted and patrolled the river banks for days.
The newspaper article, which is uncredited, says that on December 5 of that year residents of High Street, which runs one block north of the river in downtown Union City, spotted the creature and it was a second appearance of the creature which was seen years before.
It was also seen downstream near Sherwood. At points in the river were the water was shallow, the creature was said to have half of its body out of the water and plainly seen above the stream.
Appreciate the prose of this reporter:
A whale is said to be rusticating in the placid waters of the Se Jopseh River near Union City and Sherwood, and he has scared the life half out of a dozen fishermen who caught glimpses of the monster.
A commenter on Facebook has a plausible explanation,
Most likely what they saw was a sturgeon. A 240 lb sturgeon was recorded in 2021 that was estimated to be over 100 years old
You're not likely to keep a giant sturgeon or mysterious sea creature as a pet. You can't keep these animals either.